drug price increase coping

How to Handle a Drug Price Increase (After Your Plan Resets)

December 16, 2025

Key Takeaways

Verify your new plan details immediately - Check formulary changes, deductibles, and copay structures at your pharmacy to avoid surprise costs at pickup.
Request formulary alternatives or appeals when drugs aren't covered - Ask your doctor about therapeutic equivalents or submit prior authorization requests, which succeed up to 60% of the time.
Explore multiple discount options beyond insurance - Use patient assistance programs, manufacturer coupons, or prescription discount cards like Inside Rx to save up to 80% at 60,000 pharmacies.
Shop smart with generics and bulk purchases - Generic drugs cost 80-85% less than brand names, and 90-day supplies reduce per-unit costs significantly.
Compare cash prices across pharmacies - Sometimes paying cash costs less than using insurance, and prices can vary by hundreds of dollars between locations.

Pills, a stack of banknotes, and a calculator

The Inside Rx Blog

Get the Inside Scoop on tips & tricks that may help your family save on prescriptions!

Subscribe to stay up to date with the latest news and tips

Prescription drug costs force 30% of American adults to skip prescribed medications at some point during a 12-month period. Cost-related medication non-adherence affects approximately 20% of patients who abandon prescriptions at the pharmacy counter due to price barriers.

Pharmaceutical expenditures in the U.S. grew by 13.6% during 2023, reaching $722.5 billion according to Stanford Medicine data. This spending pattern reflects prescription drug prices that average 2.78 times higher than comparable medications across 33 OECD countries.

Insurance plan resets frequently introduce unexpected medication costs. Individual employer plan deductibles averaged $1,763 in the previous year, while Medicare Part D maintained a $505 maximum deductible for 2023. Approximately 600 medications were eliminated from formularies in 2023, establishing a new record for coverage reductions.

This analysis provides specific methods to verify insurance coverage changes, identify medication alternatives when formulary exclusions occur, and implement cost-reduction strategies that maintain treatment adherence.

Check What Changed in Your Plan

Insurance plan modifications require immediate verification to prevent unexpected pharmacy costs. Coverage alterations occur annually, affecting medication accessibility and pricing structures.

Verify your insurance details at the pharmacy

Pharmacy verification provides direct confirmation of current coverage parameters. This process identifies coverage modifications before prescription fulfillment:

Present updated insurance identification to pharmacy staff
Request pharmacist verification of active coverage status
Obtain medication-specific coverage information
Confirm in-network pharmacy requirements for optimal benefits

Preferred pharmacy networks offer reduced prescription costs for plan participants. Contact member services via the insurance card telephone number to clarify coverage parameters before pharmacy visits.

Look for changes in drug coverage or dosage

Insurance providers maintain Prescription Drug Lists (PDL) or formularies, structured medication catalogs organized by cost tiers. These lists undergo regular updates that modify covered medications and associated costs.

Medication coverage verification methods include:

Benefit document review
Health plan website formulary searches
Member services contact via plan identification card number

Formulary exceptions remain available for medically necessary medications absent from covered lists. Plans maintain notification obligations for changes affecting current medications, though proactive verification prevents coverage gaps.

Understand your new deductible or copay structure

Prescription costs reflect plan architecture and pharmacy selection. Medicare Part D maintains a maximum deductible of $615 for 2026, while employer-sponsored plans demonstrate variable structures.

Post-deductible costs typically involve percentage-based payments until out-of-pocket maximums are reached. Tier-based systems position generic medications in lower-cost categories with reduced copayments, while specialty pharmaceuticals occupy higher tiers with increased cost-sharing requirements.

Inside Rx provides alternative cost reduction, offering potential savings of up to 80% across 60,000 participating pharmacies nationwide, particularly beneficial when confronting post-reset cost increases.

What to Do When Your Drug Is No Longer Covered

Formulary exclusions require specific response protocols to maintain medication access while controlling costs.

Ask your doctor about formulary alternatives

Medication removal from plan formularies necessitates immediate consultation with healthcare providers. Physicians can identify therapeutic equivalent, alternative medications with comparable clinical effectiveness, that remain on your current formulary. These substitutions often provide equivalent treatment outcomes while maintaining coverage benefits.

The alternative identification process requires:

Obtaining your plan's current formulary through the insurer's website or customer service
Presenting this documentation during medical appointments
Reviewing potential substitutes based on your clinical history and contraindications

Generic medications contain identical active ingredients to brand-name versions while typically costing 80-85% less.

Request prior authorization or appeal a denial

Medical necessity determinations allow access to non-formulary medications through prior authorization requests. This process requires physician submission of clinical documentation explaining why the excluded medication is medically necessary. Insurance appeal success rates reach approximately 60% when proper documentation supports the request.

Effective appeals include:

Physician-prepared letters of medical necessity
Documentation of failed alternative treatments or adverse reactions
Published medical evidence supporting the specific medication choice
Certified mail or fax submission with delivery confirmation records

Health insurance plans must respond within 72 hours for standard requests and 24 hours for urgent medical needs. Medicare Part D maintains a 72-hour standard response timeframe.

Explore step therapy requirements

Step therapy protocols mandate trials of lower-cost medications before insurers approve higher-tier alternatives. Plan formularies specify step therapy requirements, which physicians can verify through e-prescribing systems.

Override requests require physician demonstration of specific qualifying conditions:

Clinical contraindications to required medications
Previous treatment failures with mandated alternatives
Current medication stability that would be disrupted by formulary changes

Inside Rx provides savings of up to 80% on prescription medications across 60,000 participating pharmacies, particularly relevant for coverage denials or expensive non-formulary medications.

How to Save When Coupons or Discounts Stop Working

Manufacturer coupon expiration and discount program modifications require alternative cost management strategies. Multiple backup approaches maintain medication affordability during pricing fluctuations.

Check if your manufacturer coupon has expired

Manufacturer copay discount programs target brand-name medication costs for commercially insured patients. These programs operate under specific constraints:

Expiration dates limit program duration
Government insurance programs (Medicare, Medicaid) exclude coupon usage
Annual eligibility criteria modifications affect qualification status

Receipt submission to insurance carriers for deductible credit remains possible with certain plans. This reimbursement option functions independently of primary coverage discount programs.

Apply for Patient Assistance Programs

Pharmaceutical manufacturers operate Patient Assistance Programs (PAPs) providing financial support or free medications to eligible recipients:

Low-income patients receive primary program focus
Uninsured individuals qualify for select programs
Medicare beneficiaries access programs operating "outside the Part D benefit"

RxAssist maintains a database of available patient assistance programs. NeedyMeds provides program identification and application completion support for manufacturer assistance options.

Use Inside Rx to save up to 80% at 60,000 pharmacies

Inside Rx functions as a prescription discount solution through these steps:

Price comparison across participating pharmacies
Free discount card acquisition (registration not required)
Card presentation at pharmacy for prescription savings up to 80%

The program operates across 60,000 participating pharmacies nationwide, delivering average savings of 78% on generics and 37% on selected brand medications. Medicare, Medicaid, and Tricare beneficiaries cannot combine Inside Rx with government insurance benefits for specific medications.

Smart Ways to Cut Costs Without Skipping Meds

Multiple cost-reduction methods operate independently of insurance coverage to reduce prescription expenses:

Compare prices across local and online pharmacies

Prescription prices vary dramatically between pharmacies, sometimes by hundreds of dollars for the same medication. Online comparison tools like Inside Rx, and GoodRx allow you to find the best deals nearby. Many pharmacies will negotiate on prices if asked directly.

Buy in bulk or switch to 90-day supplies

Purchasing medications in larger quantities typically reduces the per-unit cost substantially:

Mail-order pharmacies often offer better prices due to lower overhead
90-day supplies minimize refill trips while reducing overall costs
Home delivery options like Express Scripts Pharmacy provide standard shipping at no extra cost

Use generic drugs when possible

Generic medications contain identical active ingredients to their brand-name counterparts yet typically cost 80-85% less. The average copay for brand-name drugs is $55.82, versus just $6.61 for generics. Ask your doctor to write prescriptions allowing generic substitution whenever appropriate.

Ask your pharmacist for the lowest cash price

Remarkably, paying cash instead of using insurance sometimes saves money. Until recently, pharmacists couldn't volunteer this information due to "gag clauses" in contracts with insurers. New legislation now allows pharmacists to reveal if the cash price is lower.

Inside Rx offers an additional solution, potentially saving up to 80% at 60,000 pharmacies nationwide with their free prescription discount card, no registration required.

The Inside Rx prescription discount card works like a coupon to save on the cost of prescription medication at your local pharmacy.

Mounjaro

^$ 902.69

Pen Injector, 15mg/0.5ml (Package Of 2.0 Ml)

1 Package

Ozempic

^$ 1,101.99

Pen Injector, 1/0.75(3) (Package Of 3.0 Ml)

1 Package

Conclusion

Prescription drug cost management requires systematic implementation of multiple strategies following insurance plan resets. The documented approaches provide measurable solutions to medication affordability challenges that affect 30% of American adults annually.

Insurance plan verification establishes the baseline for cost management. Formulary alternative research and prior authorization requests achieve success rates of up to 60% for coverage appeals. Patient assistance programs and manufacturer discount verification provide additional cost reduction pathways when primary coverage proves insufficient.

Pharmacy price comparison yields substantial savings due to price variations that can reach hundreds of dollars for identical medications. Generic substitution reduces costs by 80-85% compared to brand-name equivalents, with average copays dropping from $55.82 to $6.61. Cash payment verification and 90-day supply purchases further reduce per-unit medication costs through volume pricing and elimination of insurance processing fees.

Inside Rx provides immediate cost reduction through their prescription discount card system, which operates across 60,000 pharmacy locations without registration requirements. The program achieves average savings of 78% on generic medications and 37% on select brand medications, offering consistent pricing benefits independent of insurance coverage status.

The combination of insurance knowledge, medical advocacy, and systematic price comparison creates quantifiable protection against the 13.6% annual growth in pharmaceutical expenditures. These evidence-based approaches maintain medication adherence while controlling out-of-pocket expenses within established healthcare budgets.

References

Topics:

Prescription Savings Health Tips for Women Health Tips for Men